Blogs

St. Thomas, one of the beautiful U.S. Virgin Islands, is not only famous for its stunning beaches and crystal-clear waters but also for its diverse and delectable culinary scene. The island offers a wide range of dining options, from beachside shacks serving fresh seafood to upscale restaurants offering gourmet cuisine. Here, we’ll explore some of the best restaurants on St. Thomas, where visitors can indulge in a delightful gastronomic experience.

The Old Stone Farmhouse ~my favorite, hands down and it’s close to Magens Hideaway!

Situated in an 18th-century sugar plantation estate, The Old Stone Farmhouse provides a unique and elegant dining experience. The restaurant is renowned for its fine dining menu, featuring a blend of Caribbean and European influences. Guests can indulge in expertly crafted dishes made from locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a true farm-to-table experience. The wine list is extensive and thoughtfully paired with the menu. For an absolute Must-Do, you’ll want to make a reservation for Sunday Brunch; bottomless mimosas and eggs benedict are a perfect pairing!

Oceana Restaurant & Bistro

Located in Frenchtown, Oceana Restaurant & Bistro is a top choice for seafood enthusiasts. The restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring fresh catches of the day, prepared in various styles to cater to different tastes. With a cozy ambiance and friendly staff, Oceana provides a perfect setting for a romantic dinner or a family celebration. Located in Frenchtown and sitting on the water, you’ll be impressed as you walk up the stairs, as Oceana served as the Russian Embassy in 1894 for seven years. The history is rich, along with the freshly prepared desserts.

Amalia Café

For those seeking a taste of authentic Caribbean flavors, Amalia Café is a must-visit. This restaurant, located in historic Charlotte Amalie, offers a menu inspired by Puerto Rican and Caribbean cuisine. From mofongo to fresh ceviche or lobster, every dish at Amalia Café reflects the vibrant and diverse culinary heritage of the region. Order the Garlic Knots, they are worth the carbs!

Virgilio’s Restaurant

Incredibly authentic cuisine at Virgilio’s, opened in 1988. Alongside the table side Caesar Salad (yes, it sounds cliché but when they bring the anchovies, your mouth will start singing) and the handmade manicotti and ravioli with the sauces made individually to order, you will not be disappointed. And the artwork is fantastic!

Agave Restaurant

As a born and bred Texan, I know my Tex-Mex food groups! If you’re in the mood for Mexican cuisine, Agave Restaurant is the place to be and hits that deep seated need to imbibe in some tasty cuisine with a Tex-Mex flair. Located in Havensight and in Red Hook, this restaurant offers a wide selection of authentic Mexican dishes, including tacos, enchiladas, and freshly prepared guacamole. The vibrant atmosphere and extensive tequila menu make it a popular choice for both locals and tourists.

Tap & Still

If you’re looking for a laid-back atmosphere and delicious burgers, Tap & Still is the place to go. This restaurant, with locations in Red Hook, St. John and Charlotte Amalie, is famous for its gourmet burgers, craft beers, and a wide selection of sauces to complement your meal. It’s a favorite spot among locals and tourists alike for its casual vibe and mouthwatering food. Hands down, best burger on island and a perfect way to end the day after being on the water with Seas the Day Charters!

There are so many more stops to dine on St. Thomas, each offering a culinary adventure that caters to all tastes and preferences. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast, a fan of international cuisine, or someone who enjoys a hearty burger, the island’s diverse restaurant scene ensures that every visitor can find a memorable dining experience. From upscale fine dining establishments to charming local eateries, St. Thomas’ restaurants reflect the island’s rich cultural heritage and commitment to providing top-notch gastronomy to its guests.

Until next time and we can’t wait to SEA you at Magens Hideaway!